Duelling doctors intrigued Nanaimo newspaper readers

All Dr. Cluness could do was "smooth down the pillow of death…"- deceased’s husband.

I t was most unprofessional: two doctors duking it out in print with all of Nanaimo for an audience and the likelihood of humiliation and loss of his practice for the loser. But so it was, in Nanaimo, in December 1881.

It began with a letter to the editor of the Free Press by A. W.

Gamble, M. D. He accused Dr. D.Cluness, coroner and surgeon for the local collieries, of challenging his (Gamble’s) competence in treating the late Mrs. S while she was giving birth to twins.

Gamble chose to go public via the newspaper because, he said, Cluness had refused to see him one-on-one and, "If I were guilty of malpractice in this case and he knew it, it was his duty as a coroner to summon a jury and have the matter properly investigated."

Gamble proposed arbitration by a third physician and that he and Cluness each post a bond of $ 100-$ 500 which would go to the party deemed to have proved his case: "The proposal I think is a very fair one… I want no newspaper warfare[!] in the matter but require of the Dr. a congenial reply, will he accept the proposition or not?" His proposed "bet," as she termed it, drew a response from Margaret Guillion who’d helped nurse Mrs. S for 10 days. At all times, she declared, Gamble’s instructions had been strictly followed, and all the nurses were experienced. She didn’t wish to say more "but any certificate I can sign would not be favorable to Dr. Gamble. I have nothing to say in his favor."

Most damning was a letter from William Sinclair, husband of the deceased who chose to identify himself publicly: "… First may I plainly state that in my opinion had Dr. Gamble allowed me to bring Dr. Cluness in to assist when I wished to do so, my children would not [be] motherless today. This he prevented me from doing by menacing behaviour and by cursing and swearing and running down Dr. Cluness, completely cowing both me and the nurses [whom] he also attempts to blame… for not carrying out his directions.

"… Although I am no doctor, and consequently perhaps not perfectly capable of forming a correct judgment, yet I believe from what the nurses told me, from what I saw myself and from all I can learn, that had Dr. Gamble’s skill been greater and his management better, this great mischief and misfortune to me and my little ones would not have occurred. I think the nurses did all that even experienced nurses could do. I believe Dr. Gamble was deficient both in skill and management."

Dr. Cluness, he said, was only called in after Gamble had given up Mrs. Sinclair for dead. By then it was too late; all Cluness could do was "smooth down the pillow of death…" and try to ameliorate what he and the nurses termed Gamble’s "harsh and cruel treatment".

Sinclair said he’d tried to "ascertain the truth – the immediate cause of death was the presence of putrid matter [placenta] in the uterus up to the ninth day. When I insisted on Dr. Gamble telling me the immediate cause of… death, he said a small piece of such matter, about the size of his thumb nail, had remained and had by absorption poisoned the system. The nurses informed me that large pieces kept coming away up to the ninth day…"

Incredibly, it got worse: Gamble had "wished to God that I and all belonging to me were dead," and threatened to sue Sinclair for his $ 50 fee. Gamble’s proposition to Dr. Cluness, Sinclair thought, was that of "a heartless, unfeeling man…"

It went on, with Dr. Cluness refuting Gamble’s claims in print. Only a week later, the Free Press reported that Dr. Gamble had placed his household goods up for sale, terms cash.

www.twpaterson. com

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Ontario trio fits the bill for 2020 Chemainus Classical Concerts series opener

Sunday performance at St. Michael’s Church in Chemainus features classic pieces

Ucluelet earthquake shakes Duncan

Did you feel it? Earthquakes Canada is confirming an earthquake at 1:35… Continue reading

First Nations land-claim case moves to Duncan for two weeks

Cowichan Tribe elders to be interviewed

Cowichan Tribes buys Genoa Bay Farm

First Nation wants to revert property back to reserve land

VIDEO: Mass coronavirus quarantines seen in China won’t happen in Canada, authorities say

‘If a case comes here, and it is probably … it will still be business as normal’

Province’s oldest practising lawyer shares advice at her 100th birthday party

Firefighters bring Constance Isherwood a cake with 100 birthday candles

Vernon woman suing McDonald’s for spilled coffee

Woman seeking nearly $10K, says employee failed to put lid on properly

Diners’ health tax not catching on in B.C., restaurant group says

Small businesses look for options to cover employer health tax

B.C. comic wins judgment after club owner slaps cellphone out of his hands

Incident happened last summer when Garrett Clark was performing in Abbotsford

Owner surrenders dog suffering from days-old gunshot wound to B.C. SPCA

The dog was also found to be emaciated and suffering from a flea infestation

B.C. man dies after police called for ‘firearms injury’ in rural Alberta

Victim is 30-year-old Greater Victoria man, say police

Most Read