Commission votes to cut down Duncan maple tree

The old maple tree on the edge of the Island Savings Centre parking lot on James Street is coming down.

The old maple tree on the edge of the Island Savings Centre parking lot on James Street is coming down.

A small but passionate group of supporters of preserving the tree turned out July 26 to hear members of the Island Savings Centre Commission vote in favour of taking down the much-discussed tree, with only Alison Nicholson voting against the idea.

The motion said “that the big leaf maple tree be removed, and the redesign of the Island Savings Centre parking lot proceed in accordance with Attachment B of the General Manager, Community Services, July 12, 2016 report.”

The decision had been deferred from a July 13 meeting pending the receipt of more information, which was considered in the intervening two weeks.

Before the meeting, commission chairwoman Sharon Jackson clarified that commission members were not simply making a recommendation to the Cowichan Valley Regional District board, they were making the final decision about the redesign of the centre’s parking lot and the future of the old maple.

They learned that, even with an extreme effort to save the tree, “limb failure” was possible within five years. Implementing that support system would cost about $10,000 with a further $1,500 needed annually to maintain it. They had also taken another look at what keeping the tree would do to the safety features designed into the new parking lot.

Prior to the decision, the commission members gave the reasons behind their votes. Several had prepared notes or even written statements.

Jackson said that concerns about the preservation of the tree had “escalated to new and troubling levels” and there had been “one death threat [to a commission member] reported to the police.”

Commissioners have read all the material and continued to consider how best to improve the parking lot.

“We must weigh the safety features of the newly-designed parking lot with the loss of those features. Second is the health and the destiny of the maple tree.”

Arborists’ reports have stated that the maple tree is old, hollow and was likely to fail sooner rather than later, she said.

However, the commission’s duty as stewards is to look at a variety of things and “make the best decision for all of our citizens”.

Jackson said she’d had a number of phone calls from taxpayers who don’t wish to “spend one penny of their property taxes on a tree that is dying.”

She said that scores of conversations in the community had reinforced this.

Jackson said it was not a good idea to make decisions about safety “based on emotions”.

Members of the audience interrupted the commission many times with questions and interjections.

Committee vice-chairman Al Siebring drew the most flak for his comments, which included pointing out, “people are not lining up with open wallets to save this tree” and that “taking the easy way” would be to acquiesce with the vocal crowd he saw before him.

“But I’ve also received a lot of phone calls and I’ve had dozens and dozens of conversations. Everywhere I go, people want to talk about this tree. And they’re almost unanimous: they can’t believe we’re having this discussion. My social media feed has exploded on this thing. I’ve had 20,000 views on this in the past month. Again, the responses in both public and private messages are running about 90 per cent in favour of taking the tree down.”

Siebring said it was important to respect all of the input, but that comments about a decision to remove the tree “coming back to bite us at the next election” were not a deterrent.

“Fair enough. But I can’t sit here and make decisions about the governance of this municipality or regional district or commission based on my political future,” Siebring said.

The issue revolves around liability and doing the right things with taxpayers’ dollars, according to Siebring.

Lori Iannidinardo, another commission member, said she thought it was unfortunate that not enough value had been placed on trees in the past and that a different approach should be taken in future.

But she would be voting to take down this particular tree as neglect had brought it to the end of its life.

Jon Lefebure, while acknowledging that some people were very attached to the tree, pointed out that nearby Vancouver Island University had been able to save a few trees during its construction and had planted others that were now growing well.

It was time to remove a tree that had “reached the end of its productive life” and move on, he said.

The only Commission member to vote against the removal was Nicholson, who said she saw it as a push to make the community more livable.

“This has become an issue that has galvanized the community,” she said, adding that she thought, “this is not much to spend for something people clearly care about.”

A question period followed

Construction work has already started on the parking lot outside the Island Savings Centre, right beside the contentious tree, and will continue throughout the summer into the fall.

The commission also passed the following motion: “To provide opportunity for the public to participate in a working group to make decisions on the trunk once the tree is removed and the trunk is relocated, as well as how the tree is honoured.”

Details on the working group will be provided in the near future.

Just Posted

Karl McPherson, left, and Mary Morrice are the new head coach and general manager, respectively, at the Duncan Dynamics Gymnastics Club. (Kevin Rothbauer/Citizen)
Manager charts a new course for Duncan Dynamics

More recreational programs to join competitive teams

Cute but fierce! Timber moonlights as an attack kitty. (Sarah Simpson/Citizen)
Sarah Simpson Column: Beware of Mr. Bite, the midnight attacker

Last week, in the middle of the night, I was awoken by… Continue reading

The province has come through with funding for Duncan Manor’s renewal project. (File photo)
Funding comes through for Duncan Manor’s renewal project

Money will come from the province’s Community Housing Fund

The former St. Joseph’s School site will remain an art studio at least into early next year. It will take some time before being converted to an addictions recovery community. (Photo by Don Bodger)
Addiction recovery facility will be all about building community together

Society on a clear path with members’ experiences to provide valuable help

At an outdoor drive-in convocation ceremony, Mount Royal University bestows an honorary Doctor of Laws on Blackfoot Elder and residential school survivor Clarence Wolfleg in Calgary on Tuesday, June 8, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh
‘You didn’t get the best of me’: Residential school survivor gets honorary doctorate

Clarence Wolfleg receives honorary doctorate from Mount Royal University, the highest honour the school gives out

Members of the Department of Fisheries and Oceans’ Marine Mammal Response Program rescued an adult humpback what that was entangled in commercial fishing gear in the waters off of Entrance Island on Thursday, June 10. (Photo courtesy Marine Mammal Response Program)
Rescuers free humpback ‘anchored’ down by prawn traps off Vancouver Island

Department of Fisheries and Oceans responders spend hours untangling whale

Cannabis bought in British Columbia (Ashley Wadhwani/Black Press Media)
Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

As stories of the horrors of residential schools circulate after the Tk’emlups te Secwepemc First Nation announced it had located what are believed to be the remains of 215 children, Grand Chief Stewart Phillip of the Union of B.C. Indian Chiefs said he feels a connection with the former students. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck
2 sides of the same coin: Ex-foster kids identify with residential school survivors

Grand Chief Stewart Phillip says the child welfare system takes Indigenous children from their families

Nathan Watts, a member of the Tseshaht First Nation near Port Alberni, shares his story of substance use, a perspective he said isn’t seen enough. (Photo courtesy of Nathan Watts)
Public shaming, hate perpetuates further substance use: UVic researcher

Longtime addict Nathan Watts offers a user’s perspective on substance use

57-year-old Kathleen Richardson was discovered deceased in her home Wednesday, June 9, 2021. Her death is considered a homicide and connected to the slain brothers found on a Naramata forest road. (Submitted)
Condolences pour in for Kathy Richardson, Naramata’s 3rd homicide victim in recent weeks

Richardson was well liked in the community, a volunteer firefighter with a home-based salon

A person receives a COVID-19 vaccine at a vaccination clinic run by Vancouver Coastal Health, in Richmond, B.C., Saturday, April 10, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jonathan Hayward
More than 75% of B.C. adults have 1st dose of COVID vaccine

The federal government has confirmed a boost in the Moderna vaccine will be coming later this month

Airport ground crew offload a plane carrying just under 300,000 doses of the single-shot Johnson & Johnson COVID-19 vaccine which is developed by the Janssen Pharmaceutical Companies at Pearson International Airport during the COVID-19 pandemic in Toronto on Wednesday, April 28, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Nathan Denette
1st batch of Johnson & Johnson vaccines won’t be released in Canada over quality concerns

The vaccines were quarantined in April before they were distributed to provinces

Most Read