Access to the Cowichan River is hot topic as spring heats up. (Citizen file)

Right to block access to river through private land OK with most

River access not OK through private land

There’s nothing like access to the icy cold waters of the Cowichan River to get a debate heated.

On April 6 the Cowichan Valley Citizen ran a story about a would-be river user upset with the recent closure of access to the popular swimming hole known as “Paradise”.

SEE RELATED: Loss of public access to popular Cowichan River swimming hole raises concerns


We Need to Bring in Freedom to Roam Legislation

The special spot off Cliffs Road has been popular for years but it’s not public property. Despite dozens of ‘No Tresspassing’ signs, people still flocked to the site, in some cases cutting existing fences to get in and often leaving all sorts of garbage — including needles — behind.

The property owners have built a fence to keep people out and while it has some up in arms about access, most are supporting Teresa Fenwick and her family.

“As many rude and entitled people we have had to deal with, we have met and heard from triple wonderful, thoughtful supportive people who have offered their help and support. As you can see from the comments, most people respect private property,” Fenwick wrote on Facebook.

She said she’s not denying access to the river, just to private land. Land that’s been private for more than 100 years.

“The garbage, needles, fires, weapons, drugs, drug deals, dog [excrement], empties…” she wrote. “And trees being cut for fires is disgusting…if you worked hard to buy land you wouldn’t want others destroying it either. No one owns the river…u can get to Paradise other ways.”

Public access, yes. Through private land, no way, say most, in their support of Fenwick.

“Seems pretty clear to me that the owners are well within their rights. It is PRIVATE PROPERTY. Just because people have been trespassing on this private property for many years doesn’t mean it’s their given right to do so,” wrote Erin Denison.

“The property owners have every right to privacy, security and peace of mind knowing their family, pets and property are secure. The access to the beach has never been public and the owner has every right to fence it off,” wrote Carol Bryson.

“I understand the frustration in not being able to get to a place you have gone to for years, but the fact is, this is someone’s land and their rights need to be respected,” wrote Jodi Benson. “If they want to build a fence on their property, they have that right. Liability issues are just the tip of the iceberg for a land owner. Privacy needs to be respected.”

Still, access points to the river are a hot topic.

“It should be a priority for our municipal council to help the public access our river. The public has been using those trails for decades,” wrote Meghan Robertson on the Citizen’s website. “It’s no good saying that the river is public when only wealthy property owners can access the best swimming holes. I think our mayor is correct that no, the access we have is not enough anymore and something should be done for the people of the Cowichan Valley to make sure there is enough access to the river.”

Rick Bryan of North Cowichan wrote a letter to the Citizen proposing working to get a Freedom to Roam law passed in Canada that would allow “citizens to access wilderness through private property”.

“As a recreational whitewater paddler, I’m aware of the grave concern recreationalists face all over the globe when riverfront becomes private property, and reasonable access is denied. Swimmers, tubers, anglers, and paddlers all need access points to our rivers,” he said.

“Folks, we have work to do! We must strive toward ‘Freedom to Roam’ and we must work aggressively to limit the current ‘Freedom to NIMBY’.”

Read more of the discussion here:

Just Posted

Cowichan Crushers advance in Coastal Cup tourney

The U14 Gold girls soccer team put together a 2-0 win over the Albion Wolves

Column Drivesmart: DriveABLE being replaced with ERA for senior drivers

The ERA is designed as an assessment which provides RoadSafetyBC with comprehensive information

Vandekamp hiring an important step for Cowichan Capitals

Former Nanaimo coach brings considerable experience and a winning attitude that’s been lacking

Lake Flashback: Three heavy subjects: private forest lands, teachers striking, and parking bylaws

There’s also a bit of fun, too, as we enjoy going back to the ’70s

Chris Wilkinson column: Acceptance can be dangerous

She and her husband were headed down the path of least resistance with their health

NDP gives Liberal budget ‘failing grade’ on gender equality

Nanaimo-Ladysmith MP Sheila Malcolmson said budget doesn’t do enough to focus on pay equity

B.C. town No. 1 honeymoon destination worldwide

Vernon came out on top in’s list of top 18 honeymoon destinations worldwide

Men arrested at Starbucks say they feared for their lives

Rashon Nelson and Donte Robinson were arrested in a Philadelphia Starbucks, becomign viral video

Olympic gold now official for B.C. weightlifter

Christine Girard’s bronze medal from 2012 Olympics upgraded to gold, IOC announces

Did a Canadian shoot down the Red Baron? A century later, debate hasn’t quit

Om April 21, 1918 two Canadians in their canvas-covered Sopwith Camel biplanes engaged the enemy

VIDEO: Canadian teen lands invite to Royal wedding

Prince Harry and Meghan Markle have invited Faith Dickinson, founder of Cuddles for Cancer

B.C. liquor server wage to be phased out by 2021

Piece work pay for farm workers rises, but stays in place for now

Vancouver Whitecaps sign 16-year-old B.C. player

Grade 10 student from Langley joins MLS club

Folk legend Arlo Guthrie returns to Vancouver Island MusicFest

Island MusicFest executive producer Doug Cox went to the well one more… Continue reading

Most Read