Court finds against Ministry of Fisheries

There are many people in the Cowichan Valley dedicated to returning our wild salmon runs to their previous abundance.

And they were heartened to hear news of a court decision against the Minister of Fisheries and Oceans for failing to protect wild fish stocks.

On May 6, 2015, Justice Rennie of the Federal Court ruled that the Minister for DFO could not delegate her authority to Marine Harvest to determine whether or not introducing smolts carrying the piscine reovirus could be harmful to wild fish stocks. (Reovirus is not harmful to humans.) The Minister had tried to argue that under the Fishery (General) Regulations (FGRs) and the Pacific Aquaculture Regulations, Marine Harvest had the right to transfer live fish to their oceanbased pens in the Broughton Archipelago.

But Justice Rennie did not see it that way. And as part of his decision, he referenced the Cohen Commission into the Fraser River Sockeye – that diseases on fish farms posed some risk to wild salmon and that “DFO’s number one priority in conducting fish health work” should be protecting the health of wild stocks.

Marine Harvest argued that there is no conclusive link between the piscine reovirus and the much more serious disease, Heart and Skeletal Muscle Inflammation (HSMI), so their decision to move the smolts to open water was a sound one.

The Minister “sheltered behind Marine Harvest’s evidence” said the judge, noting

that the Minister presented no evidence.

The judge pointed out that his role was not to judge the merits of the science but the “reasonableness of the Minister’s exercise of discretion”.

And that is where the real story lies. In its submission, DFO said the Minister depended on guidance from expert advisers and scientific criteria when setting licence conditions.

But the judge noted that the Minister said nothing about the science used to help determine those conditions and used “unsupported statements of science.”

The federal court decision went on to say that “The precautionary principal recognizes, that as a matter of sound public policy, the lack of complete scientific certainty should not be used as a basis for avoiding or postponing measures to protect the environment, as there are inherent limits in being able to predict environmental harm.”

The licence allowed Marine

Harvest to move fish from a diseased stock as long as it did not require treatment.

The judge found that the licence was inconsistent with the FGRs and that it relieved Marine Harvest from its obligation under the law to test for harmful disease since HSMI does not manifest until five to nine months after smolts are transferred to the sea.

The judge found that although the Minister could delegate authority to Marine Harvest to determine if a transfer of fish was permissible, the delegation was not proper because the licence gave unlimited discretion to Marine Harvest to determine the transfer and supervisory control over the assessment should have remained with the department.

The ultimate decision is that parts of Marine Harvest’s licence were declared invalid and to have no force and effect.

It is suspended for four months to allow the Minister to make the necessary regulatory changes for licences.

Whether you support finish aquaculture or not, I think we can all agree that DFO’s main responsibility is the preservation of fish stocks and this decision raps the Minister’s knuckles for forgetting that.

Jean Crowder is the Member of Parliament for Nanaimo-Cowichan. She can be reached at her Duncan office at 250-746-4896.

Just Posted

Jared Popma recently streamed a live concert from the Cowichan Performing Arts Centre. (Ashley Daniel Foot photo)
21-year-old jazz artist talks favourite tunes and joys of music theory

Jared Popma recently streamed a concert from the Cowichan Performing Arts Centre

Vetch cover crop beginning to flower. (Mary Lowther photo)
Mary Lowther column: Vetch and crimson clover to the rescue of soil fertility

I add dry organic fertilizer as plants use up what is in the soil.

Sarah Simpson
Sarah Simpson column: A shift in perspective can sometimes change everything

Have you even been forced to wake up at 5:30 on a Saturday

Black Press file photo
RCMP seek suspect in Vancouver Island-wide crime spree

Crimes stretched from Deep Bay to Qualicum, Ladysmith, Chemainus and Youbou

North Cowichan’s committee of the whole have rejected staff’s recommendation to limit the use of fireworks to Halloween. (File photo)
North Cowichan rejects limiting fireworks to Halloween

Municipality decides staff recommendation would be unpopular

Marco Mendicino, Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship during a press conference in Ottawa on Thursday, May 13, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
Canada to welcome 45,000 refugees this year, says immigration minister

Canada plans to increase persons admitted from 23,500 to 45,000 and expedite permanent residency applications

Emily Steele holds up a collage of her son, 16-year-old Elijah-Iain Beauregard who was stabbed and killed in June 2019, outside of Kelowna Law Courts on June 18. (Aaron Hemens/Capital News)
Kelowna woman who fatally stabbed teen facing up to 1.5 years of jail time

Her jail sentence would be followed by an additional one to 1.5 years of supervision

Cannabis bought in British Columbia (Ashley Wadhwani/Black Press Media)
Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

Cpl. Scott MacLeod and Police Service Dog Jago. Jago was killed in the line of duty on Thursday, June 17. (RCMP)
Abbotsford police, RCMP grieve 4-year-old service dog killed in line of duty

Jago killed by armed suspect during ‘high-risk’ incident in Alberta

The George Road wildfire near Lytton, B.C., has grown to 250 hectares. (BC Wildfire Service)
B.C. drone sighting halts helicopters fighting 250 hectares of wildfire

‘If a drone collides with firefighting aircraft the consequences could be deadly,’ says BC Wildfire Service

A dose of the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine is pictured at a vaccination site in Vancouver Thursday, March 11, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jonathan Hayward
NACI advice to mix vaccines gets varied reaction from AstraZeneca double-dosers

NACI recommends an mRNA vaccine for all Canadians receiving a second dose of a COVID-19 vaccine

A aerial view shows the debris going into Quesnel Lake caused by a tailings pond breach near the town of Likely, B.C., Tuesday, Aug. 5, 2014. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jonathan Hayward
Updated tailings code after Mount Polley an improvement: B.C. mines auditor

British Columbia’s chief auditor of mines has found changes to the province’s requirements for tailings storage facilities

A North Vancouver man was arrested Friday and three police officers were injured after a 10-person broke out at English Bay on June 19, 2021. (Youtube/Screen grab)
Man arrested, 3 police injured during 10-person brawl at Vancouver beach

The arrest was captured on video by bystanders, many of whom heckled the officers as they struggled with the handcuffed man

Most Read