Crematorium decision sets worrying precedent

The Cowichan Valley Regional District has every right to be surprised – and concerned.

Every other municipal government in the province should be concerned, too.

A precedent-setting decision by the BC Court of Appeal that will allow the crematorium in Sahtlam to operate as a commercial business flies directly in the face of the P-1 (Parks and Institutional) zoning.

The court essentially decided that the crematorium is an institution, whether it is run for profit or not.

Therefore, it can operate commercially on the site.

We have to wonder if the appeal judges considered what this truly means.

Institutional zoning was designed as separate from commercial zoning.

This ruling threatens to make the two one and the same.

Technically, any business could argue that it is providing a service to the community. That’s why they are in business. People will pay them for what they offer.

But creating a new class of commercial zone was never the intention of municipalities when designating land institutional.

The for-profit facilities allowed on institutionally zoned land are very specific and spelled out in area bylaws. These include private schools, seniors homes, and airports. This court ruling arbitrarily adds to this list.

It takes the decision out of the hands of the community it will affect. Our local governments, elected by us to serve our interests, should be the ones making such land-use decisions.

It’s not that the crematorium is not an important facility.

The CVRD has long recognized and allowed its use for ceremonial purposes. The allowance for a “religious facility” is specifically spelled out in the P-1 zoning bylaw for Area E. The new facility built a few years ago is inarguably environmentally superior to the old one. Perhaps there is even a need for a commercial cremation facility in the Cowichan Valley.

But where it could go should have been a decision made by the community with everybody’s eyes wide open.

All municipal eyes in the province will now likely be on what happens next.

Submit your letter to the editor online

We want to hear from you!

Submitting a letter to the editor is now easier than ever – you can do it online by going to the Cowichan Valley Citizen website,, and clicking on the Opinion tab. Then click Send us a letter.

Write 300 words or less on the topic of your choice, include your full name (first and last), and a town you hail from.

Include a phone number (which is not printed) so that we can verify your authorship.

Just Posted

The circus is coming back to Duncan; get free kids tickets from the Citizen

This is a real, old fashioned circus, in a big tent, featuring high wire acts, clowns, and more

New ‘Patio Portal’ planned for Cowichan Bay

Project will improve public access to the Cowichan Bay waterfront

What you said: Pay for use water a controversial topic

Public works crews have been busy for the last four years installing water meters

Pair of 11-year-old Cowichan highland dancers heading to Virginia for competition

Amelia Marsh and Maya Sundstrom are excited about the possibilities

VIDEO: ‘Thrones,’ ‘Fleabag’ top Emmys

Billy Porter makes history as first openly gay black man to win best drama-series acting Emmy

‘This is savage’: Strip club owner suspects arson in Williams Lake fire

Investigators on scene to determine cause of fire that destroyed at least two businesses

B.C. VIEWS: School officials join fact-free ‘climate strike’

Students, public get distorted picture of greenhouse gases

Judge rules cops did not coerce statement from B.C. man accused of assaulting sex worker

Defence wanted Vernon’s Curtis Sagmoen’s video interview with police deemed inadmissible

GRAPHIC: Tortured cat found with string around its neck in Kelowna alleyway

City crews have been contacted and are on the way to pick up the dead feline.

Firefighters may be needed for paramedic apartment access, experts say

Better coordination recommended in urban B.C. 9-1-1 calls

B.C. police chief to speak to Liberal candidate after second ad appears featuring photo of officer

Jati Sidhu had said an ad with the same photo posted last Friday was ‘not appropriate’

Tour de Rock ride kicks off in the North Island

I would ride all day in the rain if it means raising money to help these kids”

Three B.C. moms to launch CBD-infused water

Three friends say benefits may include anxiety relief, pain management

Most Read