Duncan maple tree demolition issue not about safety or money

In light of the controversy surrounding the maple tree at the Island Savings Centre, I feel called to distill the facts.

In light of the controversy surrounding the maple tree at the Island Savings Centre, I feel called, as an arboricultural professional, to distill the facts. Despite widespread claims that the tree is a safety and financial liability, there is no credible evidence to support this.

The initial arborist report, which allegedly condemned the tree, was never released due to a non-disclosure clause and given the unwillingness of the arborist to defend their findings should, at this point, be deemed irrelevant.

What is very relevant is the second report (available publicly under July 26 ISCC agenda at www.cvrd.bc.ca/1775/Island-Savings-Centre) prepared by renowned lecturer and consulting arborist Dr. Julian Dunster which rates the tree as a low-moderate risk — a rating common among urban trees. Dr. Dunster’s report also clearly states: “The overall tree health is quite good, notwithstanding the extensive decay in the heartwood area. There is abundant evidence of response growth, the new sprouts are growing well, and the overall form of the tree is typical of a bigleaf maple that has been previously crown reduced.”

No costing of tree maintenance was provided in Dr. Dunster’s report.

Compared to other bigleaf maples on UBC’s Big Tree Registry, our James Street Maple, at 197 cm in diameter, would rank as the largest caliper bigleaf maple on South Vancouver Island. Given the droves of tourists flocking to horticultural attractions in nearby Victoria, would it not be sensible to consider retaining such an exceptional specimen?

It’s time to look past politics and emotions and look at the data. Arguments for removing the tree are weak and unsupported.

This issue is not about safety or money; it’s about the competence of our elected officials in managing our public green infrastructure.

 

Todd Gesshe

ISA Certified Arborist

Just Posted

Hometown Hockey visits the home of the Big Stick

Cowichan hosts Rogers broadcast and accompanying festival

North Cowichan raising stink over foul odours

Smell from Chemainus facility an issue for years

Find Your Fit at WorkBC tour in Duncan Jan. 23

Event to be held at Cowichan Secondary School

Cowichan wrestling camp kicks off New Year

Camp attracts wrestlers from Valley, Victoria and Mainland

VIDEO: It’s Hometown Hockey time in Cowichan!

See our videos and pictures by our reporters from the big event at The Stick.

VIDEO: Fuel truck and train collide in B.C. causing massive fire

More emergency crews are still arriving on scene of a massive fire at the Port Coquitlam rail yard.

Back to work: U.S. government shutdown ends after Democrats relent

Short-term spending measure means both sides could see another shutdown stalemate in three weeks

Man lives despite malfunctioning defibrillator at B.C. arena

A middle-aged man went into cardiac arrest after at game at Pitt Meadows Arena last Wednesday.

Cause of Northern B.C. seaplane crash released

TSB releases report on seaplane crash during a water landing in 2016 near First Nations community

Vancouver police crack down on pop-up pot vendors

Officers raided merchants’ tables on Robson Square late Sunday

Bell Media, NFL take appeal over Super Bowl ad rules to top court

At issue is a ban on substituting American ads with Canadian ones during the game’s broadcast

Crown seeks 4.5 years jail for B.C. woman convicted of counselling tax evasion

Debbie Anderson the latest from group to face jail for teaching debunked ‘natural person’ theory

Road conditions wreak havoc for Comox Valley drivers

Icy road conditions early Monday morning kept first responders very busy throughout… Continue reading

Most Read