Editorial: Being intoxicated must not be allowed to stand as a viable defence in criminal cases

Hamnett has permanent physical damage to one hand from the attack

Alberta Judge Michele Hollins delivered a truly horrifying court decision this week, one that we feel must go to the Supreme Court of Canada, or risk setting back Canadian law by decades.

The case is pretty straightforward, and so, one would have thought, would be a guilty verdict. Instead, Matthew Brown got an absolute gift of an acquittal that leaves us afraid for the future of justice in this country.

RELATED: Alberta man who took magic mushrooms found not guilty of assaulting professor

Brown, now 29, was a student at Mount Royal University when he drank and got high one night on magic mushrooms, voluntarily, and proceeded to strip naked, break into professor Janet Hamnett’s home, and violently beat her with a broom handle until she was able to escape.

His defence? He was too high to be held responsible for his actions. And oh, he’s actually a really nice guy and he’s really sorry. And he hadn’t had a bad reaction when he did magic mushrooms before.

In what world is this man acquitted? Hamnett has permanent physical damage to one hand from the attack, not to mention the psychological trauma.

What if he’d killed her? Or raped her? Or cut off an appendage? Would he still have been acquitted, because being high made it not his fault?

The bottom line is that he chose to become so intoxicated, and he’s responsible for what he did while in that state. Legal decisions have reflected this view in the past. We don’t let drunk drivers who kill someone off the hook because they were drunk behind the wheel. In fact, that’s an aggravating factor, not the opposite.

Our justice system cannot start allowing criminals to get away with their crimes as long as they’re high or drunk enough. It would lead to anarchy, and a country we don’t want to live in. We’d argue there’s clearly an element of white, middle class privilege happening here as well. We cannot imagine such a verdict for a First Nations man, or a black man, or an immigrant. Or a homeless drug addict. Someone who’s not the captain of a hockey team.

This case must be appealed, all the way to Canada’s top court if necessary. Intoxication is not a defence.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Someone used this counterfeit $50 to pay for items at the Hospital Auxiliary Thrift Store in downtown Duncan in April 2021. (Kevin Rothbauer/Citizen)
Duncan businesses warned of counterfeit cash

Fake $50 passed at Hospital Auxiliary Thrift Store

Martin Drakeley, North Cowichan’s manager of fire and bylaw services, says the municipality’s fire halls have responded to more fires than usual this spring. (File photo)
Dry weather, wind leads to more brushfires this spring in North Cowichan

‘Be safe. Be fire smart. Be situationally aware.’

This Earth Day, Cowichan Valley residents are being asked to clean up where they are. (File photo)
Cowichan ‘Clean Where You Are’ campaign starts on Earth Day

Take a bag, one glove, long tongs, and go pick up!

City of Duncan considering an average 3.51 per cent tax increase for 2021. (File photo)
Duncan considers average 3.51% tax increase for 2021

Homeowners would see a $43 increase over last year

A lone traveler enters the Calgary Airport in Calgary, Alta., Monday, Feb. 22, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh
VIDEO: Trudeau defends Canada’s travel restrictions as effective but open to doing more

Trudeau said quarantine hotels for international air travellers will continue until at least May 21

Chart from the April 20 B.C. budget shows sharp dip in real estate sales early in the COVID-19 pandemic and the even steeper climb since late 2020. (B.C. government)
Hot B.C. housing market drives property transfer tax gains

B.C. budget boosts tobacco, sweet drinks, carbon taxes

Cannabis bought in British Columbia (Ashley Wadhwani/Black Press Media)
Is it time to start thinking about greener ways to package cannabis?

Packaging suppliers are still figuring eco-friendly and affordable packaging options that fit the mandates of Cannabis Regulations

President Joe Biden holds a virtual bilateral meeting with Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau. (AP Photo/Evan Vucci)
U.S. to help Canada with more COVID-19 vaccine supply, Biden says

The U.S. has already provided Canada with about 1.5 million doses of the AstraZeneca vaccine

B.C.’s 2021 budget is trending in the right direction to support farmers, says the BC Fruit Growers’ Association. (Phil McLachlan - Capital News)
BC Fruit Growers’ Association gives thumbs up to provincial budget

BCFGA general manager said budgetary investments put farming industry on a good trajectory for recovery

Some Saanich firefighters have expressed concerns about first responders in the Island Health Region not being prioritized to receive the COVID-19 vaccine as an outbreak at a fire station would make service delivery a challenge. (Devon Bidal/News Staff)
Some Island firefighters not prioritized for COVID-19 vaccine despite working on frontlines

Saanich members express frustration, department calls on Island Health to take action

B.C. Finance Minister Selina Robinson leaves the assembly with Premier John Horgan after the budget speech Tuesday, April 20, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chad Hipolito
Paid sick leave for ‘hard-hit’ workers left out of provincial budget: BCGEU

‘For recovery to be equitable it requires supports for workers, not just business,’ says union president Laird Cronk

A large crowd protested against COVID-19 measures at Sunset Beach in Vancouver on Tuesday, April 20, 2021. (Snapchat)
VIDEO: Large, police-patrolled crowds gather at Vancouver beach for COVID protests

Vancouver police said they patrolled the area and monitored all gatherings

Most Read