Private auto insurance no magic wand

“Alberta auto is in crisis” — a fully private insurance model

Private auto insurance no magic wand

Re: “Insurance Bureau VP touts advantages of private sector auto insurance to Cowichan crowd”, (Citizen, Jan. 24).

The Insurance Bureau of Canada (IBC) is currently doing a tour of B.C. touting how the secret to solving all the challenges facing the auto insurance industry in our province is privatization — an unsurprising conclusion for the association that represents private insurers.

What IBC’s Pacific VP, Aaron Sutherland, is not telling his B.C. audiences is that his IBC counterparts are spreading similar doomsday messages in other provinces. This month alone, the IBC’s Western VP, Celyeste Power, stated “Alberta auto is in crisis” — a fully private insurance model — while the IBC’s President Don Forgeron wrote “auto insurance systems across the country are broken”. Ontario, another fully privatized jurisdiction, has just had its highest auto insurance rate increases in eight years and, despite the IBC’s claim, many people there pay premiums far in excess of those here in B.C.

There is no doubt that we have some serious, and well-publicized, challenges with our auto insurance system here in B.C. However, whether we have a public or private auto insurance system, the same underlying problems of a record number of crashes and claims, and record high claims costs, would still need to be addressed — simply making a change to private insurance would not solve these issues.

For the IBC to suggest a switch to a private insurance model is some kind of magic wand that will cure all our ills is completely disingenuous and baseless, especially at a time when they are clearly aware of the challenges facing private insurance models across Canada.

There is no doubt, there are profound financial concerns at ICBC but government and ICBC are addressing those concerns with major reforms to the auto insurance system in B.C. — reforms which the IBC has also publicly supported.

Bill Carpenter

Vice president, Insurance


Just Posted

Indoor tournaments showcase Cowichan Valley field hockey talent

Local players on top two teams at senior tournament, Cowichan Typhoons finish second at U18 event

Strangers save life of hiker in Cowichan

Hike up Cobble Hill Mountain turns into ambulance ride, surgery

Editorial: Invasive species a problem that didn’t need to be

You see, parrot’s feather didn’t just naturally sprout in the area.

LAKE FLASHBACK: Big pot bust, big penny drive, and big storm: all the February news from the past

There was plenty going on at this time over the years; even John Ward was stonewalled by Victoria

Mary Lowther column: Time to start sprouting some peas

Reserving a bed just for seed-saving has to be an important fixture in my garden plans.

Fashion Fridays: Up your beauty game

Kim XO, helps to keep you looking good on Fashion Fridays on the Black Press Media Network

Cowichan Coffee Time: New faces and chipping in

• Duncan resident Gianpierro (GP) Denomme is the newest volunteer member of… Continue reading

Concern over student vaping grows in Vancouver Island schools

Island Health officer says parents and educators have ample reason to be concerned

Third measles case in Vancouver prompts letter to parents

Measles is highly contagious and spreads easily through the air

Missing woman last seen on Vancouver Island

Heather Anne Limer has been missing since Jan. 24

January home sales were weakest since 2015, average national price falls: CREA

CREA says the national average price for all types of residential properties sold in January was $455,000

B.C. man known as ‘Papa Jimmy’ dies making daily trek to his wife

Maple Ridge 85-year-old made visits to New West for 12 years

Wilson-Raybould’s cabinet move due to departure from team: Trudeau

Jody Wilson-Raybould suddenly quit the cabinet this week, but Trudeau isn’t saying

VIDEO: Canada Winter Games athletes arrive in Red Deer from B.C. and beyond

Up to 3,600 athletes, managers and coaches will arrive throughout the day Thursday and Friday

Most Read