Proportional representation not a dream of the fringe

I think that helps illustrate that proportional representation is not merely the pipe dream of hippies and fringe weirdos.

In his recent letter to the editor, Martin Barker states he didn’t hear any talk of voter reform in the last federal election. That’s odd since it was a major platform point for both the Liberals and the Greens. It’s why the Liberals are currently following up on their promise that 2015 would be “the last first-past-the-post election.” If Barker didn’t hear any of this, he must not have been listening.

Barker also goes on to say that proportional representation “favours fringe parties and special interests.” That doesn’t make sense though. If 10 per cent of Canada votes Green, and the Green Party then receives 10 per cent of the seats, how does that “favour” the Greens? It doesn’t give them an inordinate amount of power. It only gives the voters and that party a political voice that is proportional to their numbers. To me, that sounds completely fair.

Barker also points to Spain and Australia as reasons everyone should be terrified of proportional representation. I think he should mention how terrifying it was that Harper’s Conservative party had a majority government with less than 40 per cent of the vote and basically did whatever they wanted for four years. And gee whiz, now the Liberals have that same absolute power. I find that pretty frightening, personally. I don’t think any party should have absolute power.

In fact, in contrast to Barker’s comments, I would like to point out that all seven countries ranked above Canada and the U.S. in the Human Development Index (a.k.a. the Standard of Living Index) use proportional representation: Norway, Australia, Switzerland, Denmark, Netherlands, Germany, and Ireland. I think that helps illustrate that proportional representation is not merely the pipe dream of hippies and fringe weirdos. It is a legitimate system that works in the most successful, sophisticated countries in the entire world. Perhaps it’s time we consider trying it.


David Barnes

Shawnigan Lake

Just Posted

Caps’ Pochipinski locks up scholarship

Forward bound for Colorado College

Duncan man gets jail time for beating puppy to death

Robert Carolan is also banned from owning animals for a decade

Column: Keeping animals off roads is no simple task

Where I originally come from, it’s moose, which can weigh twice as much as an elk

Column David Suzuki: More action needed to ensure safe water for First Nations

All nine water systems on Lytton First Nation land have been under boil water advisories

Coming up in Cowichan: Irrigation; Palestinian children; fun with fungi

The Cowichan Watershed Board is presenting a free efficient irrigation workshop

SAR suspends search for missing man at Sun Peaks

RCMP will continue to search for a missing man near Kamloops but SAR has suspended their role

B.C. Ferries aims to improve passenger perceptions

CEO acknowledges corporation is sometimes seen in a negative light

Lottery will help save children’s lives

Each ticket gets you a chance to win a lot of money, while helping a lot of kids

B.C. RCMP officer officially cleared in car wash shooting incident

A report found the Salmon Arm officer fired 14 bullets at the man’s truck

Wounded Warrior Run stops in Port McNeill

For Jacqueline Zweng, the Wounded Warrior Run is a personal matter.

Interest in Canadian Armed Forces remains high

Canada seeks about 5,000 recruits each year for its regular forces of about 68,000

Rules reviewed to keep drug money out of B.C. real estate

Investigator looking at loans as well as casinos, David Eby says

Most Read