Same forest: different planets

My heart sinks as I survey several football fields of patch clear cutting.

Same forest: different planets

As beauty is in the eye of the beholder, so is a forest. To the one who beholds a forest as a “tree factory,” to quote a forester I recently met on Stoney Hill, revenue is the highest value and thus most beautiful. To one who places ecology (the inter-dependence of living organisms — from micro-organisms to trees) as the most essential value, then the long term health of a forest is the most beautiful. Herein lies the confusion of the forest debate that will continue until we finally have full and meaningful public dialogue about the management of our forests.

As exemplified in articles by the mayor and me quoting forest experts, there are two points of view, two different languages — that of the industrial professional foresters (RPFs), managing tree plantations for now, in contrast with RPFs who prioritize ecological values: complex forests forever.

If you’ve read the mayor’s recent letter in response to my last letter about Stoney Hill, you would probably not guess that we are friends. I have the greatest respect for the mayor and yet our understanding of forest issues could not be more different, (as is our language). If you listen to us converse we might as well be from two different planets — Venus and Mars.

For instance, when the mayor describes the salvage on Stoney Hill as “highly selective harvesting,” he quotes his experts. In turn, I would quote alternative experts:

Local logging supervisor and cable logger, Gino Gaiga, who recently entered the debate, (a courageous act for a logger of 40 years), says, “The harvesting on Stoney Hill is clear cutting. The few blowdown trees could have been extracted using a low impact machine that reaches out with a long line, with few live trees removed, and without skid trails,” (read roads big enough for machines — see videos on

I contact Ray Travers, respected retired RPF, to ask for a forestry prescription of “highly selective harvesting” in the context of salvaging a natural occurrence. Travers says, “It requires clarity of intent and prudence to ensure good silvicultural decisions about what trees to leave and what trees to take. In conventional silvicultural practice this means pre-marking trees.”

On Stoney Hill, flagging tapes marked boundaries of salvage areas rather than a tree here or there to be removed. In the end, within the patch cuts, a tree here or there was left standing.

When Gaiga and Travers describe what could have been done to alleviate fire risk while maintaining the canopy on Stoney Hill, my heart sinks as I survey several football fields of patch clear cutting. Then a forester tells me that the clear cutting is a “light touch” and I am mystified. For forestry, like ecology, like everything, depends on the beholder. Let the public debate begin now.

For an in-depth response to the mayor’s letter, go to

Icel Dobel

North Cowichan

Just Posted

Striking Western Forest Products workers could lose benefits in September

Union, forest company at odds over Vancouver Island benefit payments as strike enters third month

Flashback: Library concerns, a new park and new seniors plans

Welcome to Lake Flashback. Reporter Lexi Bainas has been combing through old… Continue reading

Take your family to the Cobble Hill Fair this Saturday

Animals, rides, those wonderful displays in the hall, food and fun in store in Cobble Hill

Motor circuit expansion proposal to go to public hearing

North Cowichan gives applications third readings at packed meeting

Firefighters can’t burn down houses anymore, so they need a training facility

In the old days, everyone gathered to watch a ‘practice fire’, safety regulations won’t allow that now

New police force in Surrey must avoid VPD, RCMP errors made in Pickton case: Oppal

Boots are scheduled to be on the ground by spring 2021

Conan turns to the Property Brothers for tips on buying Greenland

Jonathan Scott suggests removing glaciers and mountains to bring in ‘more natural light’

Forests minister visits B.C. town rocked by multiple mill shutdowns

A third of Mackenzie turns out for rally, not much to cheer about

B.C. sockeye returns drop as official calls 2019 ‘extremely challenging’

Federal government says officials are seeing the same thing off Alaska and Washington state

B.C. music teacher accused of sexual misconduct involving girls

Police believe other victims could be out there after the arrest of Lamar Victor Alviar

B.C. family stranded in Croatia desperate to come home

Funds being raised to bring back mom and two children

$5-million lotto ticket sold in Nanaimo

Someone matched all six numbers in Wednesday’s 6/49 draw

Most Read