Two-tier health care reduces access for those less able to pay

After reading the letter from Anthony Matthews it seems that the points he makes actually underscore why we do not want a two-tier system.

Re: “Public-private tandem system can work well” (Citizen, June 10)

After reading the letter from Anthony Matthews it seems that the points he makes actually underscore why we do not want a two-tier system.

He says that doctors in Britain work one-quarter of their time in the private system and three-quarters in the public system. That means that each doctor can see 25 per cent fewer patients in the public system than they otherwise would be able to see. Moreover, in that 25 per cent of their private patient time, those doctors are seeing fewer patients. Because the wealthy patients that they do see are paying for Cadillac service, they do not see as many of them as they would of public sector patients, so the decrease in overall patients needing medical services does not equal that 25 per cent.

British Columbia already has an alarming shortage of family doctors and nurses. We do not need to change to a system that effectively would reduce access by almost 25 per cent.

His second example, of the scarcity of expensive equipment such as MRIs in the public system would also not be helped by having a dual public-private system. He implies that it is the government monopoly that keeps the cost for these procedures high. However, access to this equipment supplied by the private sector must not only cover the costs of the equipment and staffing etc., but must also generate a handsome profit for the business owners, something the public sector does not have to do.

Moreover, when the costs for access to this private equipment are paid for by the public health care system, it just makes sense that that money is not available to purchase the necessary equipment for the public system. On both counts, a bad deal for the majority of people who need access to those tests.

In addition to the issue that two-tier health care is patently unfair to the majority of people, many studies have shown that good health is one of the key determinants of economic well being. We must ensure that we are not further widening the growing chasm between the one per cent and the rest of us by reducing access to health care for the majority.

 

Nancy Clegg

Cowichan Bay

Just Posted

Smoking ban arrives on BC Ferries this morning

No crackdown, just education as BC Ferries enacts smoking ban

Cowichan wrestling camp kicks off New Year

Camp attracts wrestlers from Valley, Victoria and Mainland

Ballet ‘Anastasia’ explores Russian mystery

Who was Grand Duchess Anastasia? What happened to her after 1918? Ballet tells gripping tale

VIDEO: It’s Hometown Hockey time in Cowichan!

See our videos and pictures by our reporters from the big event at The Stick.

Column: Trump dangerous to Cowichan Valley’s economy

The tentacles of the controversial American president reach even into the Cowichan Valley.

VIDEO: It’s Hometown Hockey time in Cowichan!

See our videos and pictures by our reporters from the big event at The Stick.

Plan your Hometown Hockey weekend

Find your favourites on the Hometown Hockey schedule

Hometown Hockey: Cowichan Capitals events

On Jan. 20 there will be special features during the game for Hometown Hockey

Coming up in Cowichan: Rain workshop, Joseph Mairs Memorial, timely film

Participants are encouraged to bring their roof dimensions

A look at potential Canadian nominees for this year’s Oscars

The nominations are to be revealed Tuesday morning for the 90th Academy Awards

B.C. expert weighs in on why kids are eating Tide pods for fun

Why are kids taking part in something completely pointless yet so risky?

Philadelphia Eagles headed to Super Bowl

After routing the Minnesota Vikings 38-7, they will face Tom Brady and the New England Patriots

VIDEO: Dramatic video shows return of rescued B.C. snowboarders

Two snowboarders were rescued near Rossland, B.C. on Sunday after being lost overnight.

Tom Brady leads Patriots back to Super Bowl, top Jaguars 24-20

New England to face winner of Sunday night’s game between Minnesota and Philadelphia on Feb. 4

Most Read