Will Duncan and North Cowichan amalgamate? It’s still too early to tell, mayors of the two communities say, in spite of the findings of a Citizen’s Assembly that concluded a merger should move forward. (Citizen file)

Citizens Assembly votes for amalgamation of North Cowichan and Duncan

But the 36-member assembly finds cost savings would be negligible

The amalgamation of North Cowichan and Duncan has been recommended by the Citizens’ Assembly.

The assembly’s final report was presented at a special meeting of the Duncan and North Cowichan elected officials on May 23.

The 36-member assembly cited a number of benefits to amalgamation, but said the cost-savings to taxpayers from such a move would be “negligible”.

“The assembly is mindful that their recommendation carries significant implications and that this is a major undertaking,” said assembly chairman Peter MacLeod.

“Nevertheless, the assembly reached a clear consensus and believes that Duncan and North Cowichan will be stronger together.”

As part of the 2014 municipal elections, both Duncan and North Cowichan councils agreed to include on the ballot a non-binding opinion question in regards to exploring the costs and benefits of amalgamating the two municipalities.

In North Cowichan, 68 per cent of those casting ballots voted in favour of conducting an amalgamation study, and in Duncan, 52 per cent of voters were also in favour.

The proposal to amalgamate would still need the approval of both councils to proceed, and then the province would need to agree, as well as the residents of both communities through a public referendum.

Assembly members concluded that a unified municipality will be better able to manage future growth, afford quality public services and infrastructure, and attract outside investment.

The assembly also reported that its members felt that residents would benefit from a more coordinated approach to local governance and planning, and was also careful to underscore the importance of protecting the area’s many distinct communities.

It believes the character of these communities can be preserved and enhanced through the development of a new Official Community Plan, as well as local area plans.

North Cowichan Mayor Jon Lefebure said each council will now individually review the assembly’s report and recommendations, which were made over a five-month period from January to April, and determine if they want to move ahead with an amalgamation process.

“We all appreciate all the work the assembly has done on this, but we’re nowhere near any final decisions on this issue,” Lefebure said.

“One of the issues raised was when and if we should hold a public referendum. The assembly said that because of the time needed to educate the public and prepare for the referendum, it should be held at the same time as the municipal election in 2018. Even if a referendum then calls for amalgamation, it could still take years because we just don’t know at this stage what will be involved.”

Lefebure said many people believed that amalgamation would be a cost-saving measure as redundancies would be reduced, but the assembly is clear in stating that likely wouldn’t happen.

“In fact, the costs could be more in some cases, and that means taxes could actually go up as a result for some people,” he said.

“I found the assembly’s report interesting, but I personally haven’t made up my mind yet. I want the chance to talk to North Cowichan’s financial people and confirm some of the report’s results. I’m not sure I understand and trust some of the conclusions that were made regarding finances.”

Duncan Mayor Phil Kent also thanks the assembly members for their hard work, but said he will reserve judgment on the report until after his council has had time to study and discuss it.

He said the fact that there may be little, if any, cost savings to amalgamation may be less important than assessing the collective vision of the citizens of both communities on what they want the outcome of the process to be.

“Amalgamation may be money neutral, but it’s an opportunity for people to put their heads together to determine what service levels they want and what they would like to see achieved,” Kent said.

“I think we have a responsibility to ensure that the public is well informed on what would be involved with amalgamation before they go to the ballot box to let their views known on this issue with confidence. There’s still a lot of work to do to fill in the gaps in the report and have further questions answered.”

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Business notes: WINGS set to close on Aug. 29

A few of the things going on in Cowichan’s business community

Collision knocks over fire hydrant on Ypres Street

Duncan firefighters quick to get situation under control

Pumps not needed on the Cowichan River this year

Wet year so far has resulted in higher water levels

Pig destined for sanctuary goes missing from Cobble Hill farm

Berleen was less than two weeks from travelling to Manitoba when she vanished

STANDING TALL: Forestry workers meet the challenges, remain hopeful

A look at the forest sector in B.C. – and those hoping for the best – amid mill curtailments

Captive fawn seized from Island home

Valley resident charged and fined under the Wildlife Act

Bamfield residents, visitors pressure province as anniversary of fatal crash approaches

Letter-writing campaign makes ‘heartfelt, emotional pleas’ to improve road conditions

Pandemic could be driving more parents to get on board with flu shot: study

University of B.C. study gauges willingness for parents to vaccinate children for influenza

Watchdog clears Okanagan RCMP in death of man after arrest over alleged stolen pizzas

The man died in hospital after having difficulty breathing and broken ribs

Health Canada says several kids hospitalized after eating edible pot products

People warned not to store cannabis products where children can find them

‘It’s not just about me’: McKenna cites need to protect politicians from threats

Police investigation was launched after someone yelled obscenities at a member of McKenna’s staff

Michigan plans dedicated road lanes for autonomous vehicles

First study of its kind in the U.S. to figure out whether existing lanes or shoulders could be used

Most Read