Cowichan dog abuse verdict ready in 10 days: judge

Judge Ted Gouge said he’s taken careful notes of everything but will now need at least 10 days to bring down his decision on an incident in which witnesses are claiming a man abused a dog on Cowichan Lake Road in April 2013.

Dog owner Brandon Scott Harrison is charged with criminal harassment, causing unnecessary pain and suffering to an animal, causing an animal to continue to be in distress and uttering threats to cause death or bodily harm.

The trial has taken a while to get to this stage because witness Shelby Harding had been unavailable but she took the stand Thursday along with SPCA special constable Matt Affleck and everything wrapped up with the lawyers’ final submissions to the judge Thursday afternoon in Duncan Provincial Court.

Defence lawyer Seth Cooper then called the accused and carefully presented Harrison’s own recollections of the case before making his own comments, noting discrepancies in the testimony.

Harrison, at 6 feet 1 inch and over 200 pounds is a big man now but he’s lost weight recently and would have been even bigger at the time of the incident, his lawyer said.

If he had actually performed some of the actions described by some witnesses, "we’d be taking about a dead dog," Cooper said.

He also pointed out that witnesses Chris and Leigh Davies "took their disdain [for Harrison] to social media, to Facebook. They wanted to name and shame Mr. Harrison. They gathered a modern-day social media mob."

No one is denying that witnesses saw Harrison disciplining his French poodle, Rufus, for running out onto the road to chase a car, "but the problem is the story does not add up," Cooper said.

Crown counsel Peter Benning centered his closing arguments on a few key points, dismissing the differences in witness testimony and focusing on their similarities.

"What is a consistent thread is that when they first saw Mr. Harrison he was very angry," Benning argued.

"They were shocked, taken aback at his actions, particularly that Mr. Harrison struck his dog with a closed fist. He actually punched the dog."

Then there was his throwing it on the ground.

"Miss Harding said it was like throwing a basketball. He didn’t deposit the dog on the ground. He acted in a violent and uncalled-for manner. That’s what struck these witnesses."

On top of that, Benning said, Harrison admits he has not struck Rufus since.

"He knows it is inappropriate. Mr. Harrison is probably ashamed of what he did and has seen the publicity, the effect of this case. He would not act this way again."

However, striking a dog like that is still "cruelty and abuse," Benning continued.

Judge Gouge will offer his judgment by video as he will not be actually needed in person.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

No more ferries will sail from Departure Bay, Mill Bay, Brentwood Bay during COVID-19 pandemic

B.C. Ferries announces major changes to sailing schedules for 60 days starting Saturday, April 4

CVRD cancels all recreation and theatre programs through end of April

Community centre and recreation programs cancelled through end of April

Archer takes on new challenges at BC Winter Games

That thrilling shoot-off resulted in one of Whitworth’s two medals

Volunteer Cowichan encouraging anyone in need to reach out

“…we really want the public to know that Volunteer Cowichan isn’t limited to only helping seniors”

Cowichan couple won’t self-isolate after returning from overseas

New law requires 14 days of self-isolation when returning to Canada

From inside the ER: B.C. doctor tells it like it is from the frontlines of COVID-19

‘Stay home. It’s working,’ says ER doctor in a Q&A discussion, ‘And please don’t worry.’

List of cancelled Cowichan Valley community events

An ongoing list of events that have been cancelled in the Cowichan Valley due to COVID-19

Don’t stop going to the doctor, just do it virtually: B.C. association

Doctors encourage patients to access telephone, online visits

Businesses advised to prepare for federal, B.C. COVID-19 assistance

Canada Revenue Agency portal expected to open next week

Dogs are property, not kids, B.C. judge tells former couple

Court decision made on competing lawsuits over Zeus and Aurora — a pit bull and pit bull cross

B.C. senior gives blood for 200th time, has ‘saved’ 600 lives

There was no cutting of cake for Harvey Rempel but he’s challenging youth to start donating blood

Trudeau commits $100M to help food banks amid COVID-19 crisis

Funds will help ‘urgent food needs’ for Canadians awaiting federal emergency benefits to kick in

How well can cell phones carry COVID-19? Disinfecting may be wise

‘You want to keep it as clean as you would normally your hands’

3M pushes back on Trump administration call to stop sending N95 masks to Canada

3M says it has already been turning out as many of the N95 masks as possible

Most Read